Talk:Madonna

Photo Should Be Changed

She looked like that for only three minutes. Madonna is barely a C and has no place in Boopedia. Here is a video that explains why. If she's allowed in then it will be a B and tiny C cup invasion! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4nyQT_QsTug

Well false or not. We can't go just go by observing, and saying so and so doesn't belong here or so and so is this bra size. Madonna is debatable, not a definite "no". She very well could had breast implants. I remember reading this somewhere, but can't remember where. Even if she's "barely" a C cup, then she still is a C. Apara 03:03, 4 January 2009 (EST)

SHE IS NOT A C cup Madonna has notoriously hyped her modest breasts, especially from 1984 till 1985 when she was fifteen pounds heavier and therefore bigger chested, she still lives of this era in regards to her chest to this day despite being it visibly much smaller looking. Many unretouched photos from before 1984 and after her legendary slimming and muscle makeover in 1986, show her to be virtually flat chested or a modest B or C cup, with the exception of her two pregnancies and any other that she chose to terminate. It is also clear from the majority her photos that she has never had an hourglass figure. Despite her measurements listed in the imbd as by her PR Liz Rosenberg as 34-23-33. Madonna is known for a flat stomach and very narrow boyish hips and virtually no hip to waist ratio. Photos show her looking more like 33B/C-27-32 in regards to physical symmetry. Her current breast size after nearly two deacdes of fat burning and muscle building workouts appears to be only about a B-cup.There are no current photos out of costume or photo shop that prove otherwise.

Hi BreastKing, please sign your remarks with ~~~~, so it's easier for us to see whom we can address to and when you wrote it. :-)

As for the discussion: The cup size is cited and sourced, and her early pics show a breast that deserves to be called a C cup. We have a lot of other models here (especially Japanese models with a so-called "metric C cup" which I'd call a small B or A cup) and again others who are always cited as having a C cup, but seem to have smaller breasts (British bra sizes for example seem to have bigger letters for smaller breasts) - but all of the are still here. There is a clear rule: As long as the information is sourced, they can stay. And the C cup is the only Boobpedia rule for a woman to become notable.

Regarding the point that she may have had a C cup, but does not have it anymore today: That does not count. Linsey Dawn McKenzie had a breast reduction, for example. She still has more than a C, but what if she had a B now? Should we delete her? The clear answer is: No. She was notable for a certain period, there exist pictures and sources for that period, so she is still notable today. The same with Madonna. She does not have to have a breast reduction for still being notable - losing weight is just the same. As for many other models who had a C cup, but might not anymore today.

And some other remarks: Please refrain from

• deleting images from articles without specifying a detailed reason
• writing from a personal point of view ("has notoriously hyped her modest breasts", see General rules and Neutral Point of View policy)
• writing down original research (this is not allowed in an encyclopedia, cite others who said so instead)
• writing whole passages without any sources at all, above all if the content is debatable, concerns living persons and might not be shared by others.

Use the discussion page instead. If a consensus is reached, the article text can be changed accordingly.

As everything you wrote violates all of the above rules, I will delete your edits completely from the article until a consensus is reached on the discussion page.

Regards

Prophecy 03:30, 4 January 2009 (EST)